Today’s organisations are so well designed that they almost run on autopilot, with existing management systems and policies leaving almost no room for error. At the very least, these institutions are stable and immune to short-term deterioration without any remarkable effort, because we have all come to value and appreciate regular and consistent results. In addition, compliance supervision and regulation make it difficult, in typical situations, for a modern organisation to mess it all up.
However, this scenario does not necessarily mean that the organisation is performing at its optimum, with efficient use of resources, both financial and human. In fact, regular and consistent results may simply point to just-acceptable performance. In any case, leadership continues to reap financial rewards, which may or may not be truly earned; after all, it has become very difficult to measure the true impact of any given leadership role.
In the majority of cases, people believe that things happen because of their authoritative influence and decisions, not necessarily because of the other people around them. In light of this situation, what seems to be needed is an investigation into the true impact of a leader in isolation.
Checking the facts
Decisions taken by leaders obviously have a significant impact on organisational results, for better or worse. But can organisations link the results directly to those actions? So many companies go bust or perform at their lowest level because of bad decisions made by weak leaders, resulting in poor performance, unhappiness, dissatisfaction, waste, inefficiency, untapped potential, poor customer service, no innovation, little motivation, and so on.
The results of many leaders are actually linked to correlations rather than causalities.
In other words, the business community has created and accepted a new definition of leadership that is based purely on correlation. The logic and conventional wisdom run as follows: company results are “acceptable,” so I, the business leader, should belong to the “good leader club.” But in reality, no one has a clue whether those results were in fact caused by the leader or by the very well-established management systems already in place.
If the result is due to the management systems and policies, then we are paying that leader a super-premium, in bonuses and other perquisites, for something that was not his or her doing.
Unfortunately, many organisations do not measure this significant unknown factor, and so automatically correlate company performance with leadership without validating the actual cause and effect. That said, a company could simply place any person with some intelligence in a leadership role and get the same results. In other words, this conventional wisdom has led to correlational leadership, not causal leadership, in many organisations.
By not demanding the analysis of cause and effect in our organisations, we are travelling on a road that leads to the end of common sense and optimal performance. Consider:
- Should boards of trustees or directors, as representatives of shareholders, not hold leaders personally accountable for establishing clearly measurable goals across the whole organisation?
- If the results of a company cannot be clearly linked to the actual decisions and strategies of a particular leader or team of leaders, how can we revisit that and make the link more apparent, using all the tools available to us?
- If boards, as representatives of shareholders, grant generous compensation and benefits to leaders who may or may not exert any influence on average results, what do we need to change to give us, as shareholders, the right to demand outperformance?
Correlational leadership can, sadly, only encourage average performance and a lack of motivation. When such thinking starts at the top, it soon trickles down through all levels of employees, who do not feel empowered to become their own leaders. Why should they bother, if adequate or average performance still earns rewards for their managers?
In the end, leadership, whether individual or organisational, demands responsibility, accountability, and the urge to do more, be more, and perform more. Personal accountability, cause and effect, is the driver that can return common sense to leadership.
Want your leadership team to think and act differently?
Our facilitation, workshops and keynotes help leadership teams face hard questions and leave with decisions.
Explore Leadership Facilitation & Capability