info@sparkchief.com
LinkedIn Medium
What We Do
Change Management & Adoption People Side of M&A and Carve-outs Leadership Facilitation & Capability
Our Solutions
Career Strategy Assessment Gryd™
Insights
Articles Books
About
Our Story Our Team Partners & Advisors Press & Media Work With Us Talk to Us
Insights  /  Articles  /  Leadership
Leadership

Key Leaders Ask, Don’t Guess

Great leaders, at all levels, guide their teams through informed decisions. But some fall into the trap of guessing based on limited information.

By Ali KursunApril 20244 min readShare LinkedIn Email

Leaders who rely on assumptions risk not only their own effectiveness, but the organisation’s sustainability. By asking deeper questions, they can uncover hidden factors that could negatively impact the outcome.

The Trap of Guessing

According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a guess means “to form an opinion from little or no evidence” or “to arrive at a correct conclusion by conjecture, chance, or intuition.” In other words, a guess is an opinion based on scarce evidence or a lucky shot in the dark. While intuition can be valuable, relying solely on hunches undermines credibility and trust. Strong leaders back their decisions with data.

So, why do some leaders gamble with their organisation’s success and reputation by guessing? Here are some common pitfalls:

  • Overconfidence: They believe they have all the answers, neglecting valuable input from others. This facade crumbles when they miss crucial information.
  • False Familiarity: They rely on past experiences that may not apply to the current situation, leading to flawed decisions.
  • Time Pressure: Feeling overwhelmed, they rush to a guess instead of taking the time to gather essential information.
  • Information Overload: Faced with too much data, they miss key patterns or misunderstand vital facts.

These reasons highlight the dangers of relying on guesses, even informed ones. Without solid evidence, even the best hunch can lead to disaster. Leaders who guess risk not only a bad decision, but also:

  • Eroded Credibility: When a guess proves wrong, their authority takes a hit.
  • Demoralised Workforce: Employees lose faith in a leader who doesn’t seek all the facts.
  • Talent Drain: Top performers seek out leaders who make informed decisions.

The Power of Asking

Leaders miss a powerful tool by skipping questions in favour of existing data. Here’s why asking questions is transformative:

  • Sets a Learning Culture: A leader who asks questions shows it is okay to not know everything, inspiring others to learn and collaborate.
  • Boosts Engagement: Employees feel valued when asked for input, fostering teamwork and engagement across departments.
  • Leads to Better Decisions: More perspectives and data from questioning lead to richer discussions and potentially more creative solutions.

Guessing vs. Asking: Short-Term Fixes vs. Long-Term Success

Guessing might seem like a quick shortcut to appearing decisive. But true leadership is about long-term success, not short-term applause. Relying on hunches instead of data and expert input undermines sustainability.

Skipping the hard work of gathering information makes you look smart in the moment, but foolish in the long run.

Cultivating a Culture of Inquiry

To encourage the entire workforce to feel comfortable in asking questions when faced with a decision, and not simply guessing what move to make, a shift in mindset is critical. Leadership needs to emphasise the priority of asking first. Replacing arrogance and a know-it-all attitude with humility can help the leadership team foster a culture that encourages transparency and questioning, no matter the seriousness or triviality of the decision.

If leaders are genuinely honest and open, sharing the same or similar vision with their employees through their own behaviour, the capacity to reach better outcomes is attainable. Transparency across the board enables better and more effective solutions. Non-transparency triggers huge hidden costs from wasted resources, finances, and time that limit the individual and organisational potential to outperform.

With transparency in one hand, and confidence in asking questions in the other, leaders have the potential to drive cultural transformation while addressing the enormous responsibility, accountability, and pressure to perform entailed by their position. Key leaders can succeed in transforming the culture with openness and innovation through their vision and compelling ideas and insights about the business. They are great listeners and champions of knowledge sharing, interested in building the best, most profitable, and sustainable businesses for the future.

The Bottom Line: Ask, Don’t Guess

Effective leaders drive success by fostering a culture of curiosity. They ask insightful questions, setting a positive example that empowers employees to do the same. This shift from assumptions to inquiries leads to better decision-making, reducing costly mistakes. An engaged workforce, energised by open communication, fuels innovation and propels the organisation forward, benefiting all stakeholders.

About the author

Ali Kursun

Ali is Managing Partner and Senior Consultant at sparkChief & Co. He specialises in organisational transformation and change management, with particular expertise in the people side of mergers, acquisitions and carve-outs. He is a Prosci® Certified Change Management Practitioner and the author of ten books and more than 100 articles on leadership and organisational change. Meet the team

Want your leadership team to think and act differently?

Our facilitation, workshops and keynotes help leadership teams face hard questions and leave with decisions.

Explore Leadership Facilitation & Capability