Starting with the graduate unemployment factor
In light of the expenditure faced by parents and students, a College Board report1 pointed out an important fact. When students take longer than two years to earn an associate degree, or more than four years to earn a bachelor’s degree, there are financial implications for the future, as students forgo earnings through reduced participation in the labour force. Consider the following.
The more quickly students earn their degrees, the more time they have to earn college-level wages and reap the financial benefits of post-secondary education. According to the US Census Bureau,2 bachelor’s degree recipients between the ages of 25 and 34 had median earnings that were 69% (US$18,876) higher than those of people with high school diplomas in 2015.
However, according to a 2013 study,3 many young adults experience a delay in the “on-ramp” from education to a full-time career and family formation. The age at which young adults reach the median wage has jumped from 26 to 30. Making the move to a decent job is difficult for many millennials, who represent 40% of the unemployed population in the US.4 This group faces higher tuition fees and student loan debt, as well as stiffer competition for employment. Part of the problem is the perceived gap between education and job readiness.
Another factor involves the expectation of lifelong learning and the continuous upgrading of skills needed to adapt to new workplace technologies, two trends that have replaced the traditional on-the-job learning process. In the same 2013 study, the authors hold that organisations should consider streamlining curricula to promote college affordability, degree completion, and the acquisition of competencies that have labour market value for employers.
A two-year study5 discussed the so-called skills gap and what managers want in an employee. When considering a composite “ideal,” the employers in the study envisioned “a hard-working individual with appropriate technical training (knowledge as well as the ability to apply technical information), solid problem-solving skills, and the abilities to communicate well, work in teams, and to continually learn new things.” The competencies they desire are not discrete skills but part of a larger whole that comprises “a person’s habits of thinking, behaving, and problem-solving.”
HR repercussions on the corporate budget
Once students enter the labour market, the problem shifts to employers. The corporate world spends billions of dollars and countless hours every year recruiting qualified employees, despite sometimes disappointing success rates, not only in hiring but also in retaining key staff. According to one research study,6 US companies spend nearly three times as much on recruiting as they do on training per employee.
The most mature recruiting organisations, defined as those considered strategic enablers of the business, spend US$6,465 per employee on average, compared with only US$3,258 among organisations at the lowest level of maturity, with reactive, tactical recruiting. But, according to the research, the investment is worth it: high-impact organisations have 40% lower new-hire turnover and can fill vacancies 20% faster.
With regard to timing, another study7 offered a different perspective. Candidates who rejected an offer pointed the finger at employer mistakes: companies do not streamline their hiring practices to prevent their best candidates from accepting another offer. Such companies also do not fully understand the target candidates’ most important priorities, a disconnect between personal and organisational goals, and so they lose them to the competition. The report cited the time to extend a job offer as three to six weeks from the candidate’s first interview, up from one to four weeks in the second half of 2015.
The additional burden of mis-hires
According to an article8 on employment costs, the four most common reasons for hiring mistakes are the following:
- At least 80% of hiring decisions are made on “gut feeling” or “based on appearances.”
- A scarcity or urgency mindset: a belief that few candidates have the necessary skills, or outside pressure on the recruiter to fill the spot immediately and settle for a mediocre candidate.
- The hiring manager is dazzled by first impressions, by how good the person looks on paper, by credentials, advanced degrees, and well-prepared interview responses.
- A lack of understanding of the difference between, or the tools to discern, top talent (based on qualifications) and best-fit talent (perhaps a better fit with the organisational culture, not just someone with the appropriate skills).
A costly hiring mistake, the cost of a “mis-hire,” includes the unconscious avoidance, denial or toleration of underperforming employees.
The higher the level of the position, the quicker the cost of a mis-hire increases exponentially.
The article cites Brad Smart, founder of Topgrading, Inc., on the potential cost of a mis-hire:
- 14 times salary for employees earning a base salary under US$100,000.
- 28 times salary for employees earning US$100,000 to US$250,000.
Besides the typical direct and indirect costs of finding new employees (such as recruiting, interviewing, reference checking, and lost productivity in the first months), employers need to consider long-term opportunity costs: substandard service; lower morale and substandard performance in other employees; missed deadlines; customer dissatisfaction with product quality or customer service, and lost trust in the company; and missed sales opportunities.
Overwhelmed by mountains of submissions from unqualified candidates, as well as by internal pressure to fill vacancies, recruiters face a predictable result: time is wasted, money is ill spent, and fallible decisions are made. This archaic process almost guarantees that people “who know people” are the only candidates hired, whether or not the applicant is a good fit. Company policies that reward employee referrals encourage this outcome. Although employee referrals may, and hopefully should, prove advantageous, the risk of presenting individuals with the wrong skills and experience can lead to trouble down the road if the referral does not meet the manager’s expectations.
In a typical situation, the hiring process drags on for weeks, sometimes months. As the employer follows the traditional recruiting method, a number of negative repercussions are possible:
- Time spent preparing the job search, writing advertisements, conducting candidate interviews, evaluating meeting results, making and negotiating offers, and filling out paperwork.
- Money wasted on advertisements, agency fees, external posting websites, new-hire sign-on bonuses (if turnover is high), and relocating key candidates (if necessary).
- Management dissatisfaction with loss of productivity, inefficient output, and a decline in potential business and company performance when a job is vacant for too long, or when another employee, unfamiliar with the job and unhappy with the added workload, is temporarily filling in.
- Unqualified applicants responding to advertisements and overwhelming hard-pressed, and too few, HR staff, who may make subjective judgment calls simply to fill another vacancy.
- Displeased shareholders, and customers, if the overall performance of the company falls off.
Lower costs are a necessity
As a society, we must each contribute to reducing the hidden costs of personal and corporate misalignment, and struggle against complacency and mediocrity. By guiding young people in their search for education and a career, as well as adults seeking meaningful employment, our efforts can significantly cut the waste of time and money. But the endeavour is not for the weak in spirit, as it will require time, intelligence, persistence, commitment, and the right vehicles.
1 The College Board, Trends in College Pricing (2016).
2 US Census Bureau, 2015 Income Data, Table PINC-03.
3 Anthony P. Carnevale, Andrew R. Hanson and Artem Gulish, “Failure to Launch,” Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce (September 2013).
4 Anthony Carnevale, Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce, cited in Leah McGrath Goodman, “Millennial College Graduates: Young, Educated, Jobless,” Newsweek (May 27, 2015).
5 Matthew T. Hora, “Beyond the Skills Gap,” National Association of Colleges and Employers Journal (February 2017).
6 Bersin by Deloitte, Talent Acquisition Factbook 2015: Benchmarks and Trends in Spending, Staffing, and Key Recruiting Metrics (April 23, 2015).
7 MRINetwork Recruiter and Employer Sentiment Study (2016).
8 Denise Corcoran, “Shocking Costs of Hiring Mistakes,” EmpoweredBusiness.com (October 30, 2013).
Looking for the talent you already have?
We help organisations see their workforce clearly, so that they hire, develop and keep the people their strategy depends on.
Talk to us