info@sparkchief.com
LinkedIn Medium
What We Do
Change Management & Adoption People Side of M&A and Carve-outs Leadership Facilitation & Capability
Our Solutions
Career Strategy Assessment Gryd™
Insights
Articles Books
About
Our Story Our Team Partners & Advisors Press & Media Work With Us Talk to Us
Insights  /  Articles  /  Talent Management
Talent Management

The Best Way to Engage Lacklustre Employees Is Not to Throw More Money at Them

No matter how financially successful a company may be, smart leaders know how to spend funds wisely, efficiently, and effectively. Yet so many organisations squander their budgets, with little or no reward, when it comes to hiring and retaining the best talent.

By Ali KursunApril 20214 min readShare LinkedIn Email

Companies worldwide continue to struggle with employee engagement and retention. An article in the Harvard Business Review1 cites a survey that analysed responses from 200,000 employees across 40 companies in 60 countries. The research found unsettling results: employees with the deepest knowledge of the company are typically the least engaged, and highly engaged senior executives are likely to underestimate the discontent on the front lines.

Given that unhappy finding, one wonders what employers are spending their money on, at least those organisations that strive to address employee disengagement. Budgets traditionally go to training, benefits, rewards, and the other typical components of an employee package.

For example, US training expenditure, including payroll and spending on external products and services, took an upward trajectory, soaring 14.2% to US$70.6 billion.2 Beneficiaries of the various training programmes included executives (10%), managers and exempt staff (22%), non-managers and exempt staff (32%), and non-exempt employees (39%). The cost of training can be high, according to HR Factbook 2015: Benchmarks and Trends for U.S. Organizations. Mature human resources organisations, integrated into the business, spend US$4,434 per employee on average, compared with just US$2,112 among those at the lowest level of maturity.3

In addition, global employers spend, on average, the equivalent of 31% of employee salary on benefits. Unfortunately, in spite of this hefty outlay, well-meaning benefits are often misdirected, as the following statistics illustrate:4

  • While nearly 90% of employers view attracting talent and improving engagement as their top objectives in offering employee benefits, only 7% of global human resources professionals consistently deliver against their benefits plan objectives.
  • Nearly half (46%) do not use analytics when devising and managing their benefits strategies.
  • Human resources teams struggle to make communications relevant to a globally diverse employee base, and often fail to make their messaging personal enough to resonate with their audience. The proof? Over 60% of employees are dissatisfied with their benefit plans.
  • Almost 70% of employees in global organisations want benefits built around key life stages, but only 46% of employers use this opportunity to engage with their workforce.

Overall, companies spend over US$720 million each year on employee engagement, a figure projected to rise to over US$1.5 billion. Once again, despite the huge outflow of funds, employee engagement is at record lows: 13%, according to Gallup.5

The need for a different accounting system

To get a better handle on the success of company strategies, an article in the McKinsey Quarterly suggested a forward-looking alternative:6 “Companies focus far too much on measuring returns on invested capital (ROIC) rather than on measuring the contributions made by their talented people. The vast majority of companies still gauge their performance using systems … based on metrics that don’t take sufficient notice of the real engines of wealth creation today: the knowledge, relationships, reputations, and other intangibles created by talented people and represented by investments in such activities as R&D, marketing, and training.”

An analysis of industry averages for revenue per employee provides an interesting perspective.7 Oil and gas companies make at least twice as much revenue per employee as other sectors, while healthcare and utilities companies also have high ratios. A possible explanation lies in the cost of doing business. Oil and gas companies spend billions of dollars on capital expenditure to build and maintain plants and rigs, while paying extra taxes and royalties. Healthcare companies spend a great deal on R&D to stay competitive, while utilities maintain vast amounts of infrastructure. These sectors generally hire specialised employees and pay higher salaries for their expertise and knowledge.

What, then, should companies spend their money on?

The answer lies not so much in implementing costly HR programmes or purchasing expensive tools as in taking practical, common-sense steps. Whether or not corporate funds are abundant, leadership should recognise the urgency of allocating resources in the ways that will garner the most profitable results in terms of revenue, shareholder satisfaction, and employee engagement.

Throwing money at traditional human resources systems and approaches that have been proven to fail, or to succeed only minimally, is not the answer to aligning employees with corporate strategies.

A key ingredient of success is getting to know your workforce. If you understand the needs and desires of your employees deeply, in conjunction with company goals, the result will prove beneficial to all parties. Listening, interacting, and responding, in other words communicating, represent the common-sense approach to determining how best to engage lacklustre employees.

1 Rob Markey, “The Four Secrets to Employee Engagement,” Harvard Business Review (January 27, 2014), citing a survey by Bain & Company, in conjunction with Netsurvey.
2 2015 Training Industry Report, cited in Training Magazine (November–December 2015).
3 Press release, “US HR Organizations Spending Increases, Following a Rise in Employee Turnover” (January 14, 2015).
4 Stephen Miller, “Missing the Mark: Employees Don’t Appreciate Benefits Spending,” SHRM.org (October 3, 2016), citing Thomsons Online Benefits, Global Employee Benefits Watch 2016/17.
5 Cited by Susan LaMotte, “Employee Engagement Depends on What Happens Outside of the Office,” Harvard Business Review (January 13, 2015).
6 Lowell Bryan, “The New Metrics of Corporate Performance: Profit per Employee,” McKinsey Quarterly (February 2007).
7 Jeff Desjardins, visualcapitalist.com (June 15, 2017).

About the author

Ali Kursun

Ali is Managing Partner and Senior Consultant at sparkChief & Co. He specialises in organisational transformation and change management, with particular expertise in the people side of mergers, acquisitions and carve-outs. He is a Prosci® Certified Change Management Practitioner and the author of ten books and more than 100 articles on leadership and organisational change. Meet the team

Looking for the talent you already have?

We help organisations see their workforce clearly, so that they hire, develop and keep the people their strategy depends on.

Talk to us