Consider this thought: if we all know the rules, and if the rules apply to everyone and are respected by everyone, then we all have a chance to progress in our chosen field. However, if there are no rules, or only half-baked rules, or some rules apply to one group but not to all, or the rules are respected by some and not by others, then it becomes apparent that the only people who can advance in their careers are those whom management arbitrarily favours, or those who dismiss the rules.
These latter scenarios do not offer a healthy climate in which an individual can succeed, nor do they provide a solid foundation on which an employer can build and maintain a sustainable career development programme. Ultimately, the most important success factor for any such programme is the assurance not only that rules exist, but also that a governance body is in place to monitor how and when the rules are applied or ignored.
The real world: rules exist
An excellent example comes from the world of sport, say, tennis. No matter how proficient a player may be, the same rules apply to all players and competitors. The difference between the world number 1 tennis player and the world number 1,000 has nothing to do with chance or fate, networking with the right people in the field, harming other players to advance one’s own interests, arbitrary decisions by a referee, or intimidation of other players. In tennis, as in all sports, rules exist, and they apply to every participant, regardless of their level of expertise and talent.
Essentially, talent is the distinguishing factor. For talent to flourish and express itself truly, we need an environment in which the rules are the same for everyone. After all, the concept of “equal opportunity” means fair competition.
Sport is just one useful example. Professionals in fields such as accounting must abide by very strict rules and procedures to avoid breaching ethical and professional standards. In fact, in nearly every type of business, association, or other entity, some form of rules and management policies is in place: restrictions that all participants are obliged to honour and comply with.
Career development programmes: the rules are iffy
Unfortunately, a majority of organisations today do not even consider establishing a set of rules to govern how employees can move forward in their careers. Many do not have a governing body to monitor the programme’s success either. The reasons vary:
- The programme might be new and still in its infancy.
- The HR professionals involved might be newcomers, with little or no practical experience in developing and implementing such programmes.
- Management oversight is minimal or non-existent, for any number of reasons: no time, no budget, or no interest.
- Leadership may only pay “lip service” to offering such a programme to the workforce.
- Internal career development managers might be overwhelmed by daily tasks and unable to focus on enhancing the programme, or on determining whether it even works.
That said, it takes little effort to create simple and feasible policy rules for any career development programme. A few suggestions might include:
- Management should provide all employees with examples of clear career paths for key roles, so that everyone knows how typical careers develop within the organisation.
- Management should ensure that detailed employee career development plans are included in performance reviews.
- Employees and supervisors should discuss the individual’s progress against career development goals every quarter.
- All employees and supervisors must attend at least one information session on the subject during each calendar year.
- There should be regular checks on succession plans to ensure that employees considered “potential candidates” actually possess the technical skills, behavioural competencies, and knowledge required for those succession roles.
The bottom line
The particulars of the rules do not matter, as long as they are fair, reasonable, and clearly understood and respected by everyone in the organisation. Establishing a practical and workable set of rules is a key factor in boosting the success of your career development programme.
No matter how much data HR uses, or how scientific and proficient HR professionals believe themselves to be, the real difference in a career development programme’s success depends on the existence and application of programme rules.
Any HR programme without a framework of rules is just a fallacy and cannot succeed.
Building career paths your people can actually follow?
Our Career Strategy Assessment helps organisations and individuals turn career ambitions into a clear, validated plan.
Explore the Career Strategy Assessment