Ultimately, after one or two years of underperformance in the role, you realised that it was a bad choice. Recognising the failure, you transferred the person to another role, hoping for a better result.
In light of the time and resources wasted, can you estimate the cost of this failure to the organisation? Many leaders cannot. But without knowing the exact costs, the “direct costs” of recruiting, hiring, and training, plus “hidden costs” such as lost productivity, poor quality, and the impact of low motivation on the other employees working with that leader, management cannot run an outstanding, successful, and truly profitable business.
Damage caused by hiring mistakes at any level
Why is it still such common practice for companies to assign leadership roles to people who are not ready, or not sufficiently prepared, for the position and its responsibilities? If they possess the technical expertise that goes with the job, they may seem the obvious and perfect choice. Yet leadership roles require a complex set of skills and abilities that individuals may not have at present and, in fact, may never have the capacity to attain.
That said, even with hindsight and experience, in light of the eventual, inevitable, and actual failure of such individuals, many hiring leaders continue to repeat this error. But when organisations give authority and accountability to someone who does not have a comprehensive understanding of what a leadership role actually means, it is very likely that the person will not be able to handle the authority and will eventually cause “collateral damage” to people, productivity, and the bottom line.
Internal and external hiring mistakes at all position levels happen more often than one likes to believe.
Unfortunately, a significant percentage of hiring decisions result from the hiring manager’s “gut” feelings, or from intense pressure to fill a vacancy swiftly just to get the job done. If qualified candidates are few and far between, managers must risk making a selection from a pool of individuals who may not necessarily possess behavioural or hard skills, such as knowledge or hands-on experience. And at times HR, the line manager, or both may find themselves fooled by a candidate’s appearance or interviewing skills, or by a blatantly close relationship to someone in management, or pressed to consider a colleague’s referral, without digging deeper to establish the person’s underlying fitness for the position.
Data proves the need for awareness
Many leaders fail to understand the true cost of hiring and retaining individuals who either do not have the necessary credentials, behavioural aptitude, and experience or, perhaps, are unwilling to exchange acceptable work for the salary they earn: in other words, bad leaders. Such costs, often overlooked, can only lead to the organisation’s long-term detriment, risking its viability, growth potential, and success going forward.
In today’s competitive market, there is a critical need, and urgency, for board members and CEOs to understand the link between weak leadership and its true cost to all stakeholders: the management team, the employee base, shareholders, clients, and customers. Part of the problem lies in where corporations spend money, for example:
- Some HR programmes do little or nothing to further the true assessment and development of the individual employee. Without such forward movement, innovation and creativity stagnate, dragging down the quality and reliability of the company’s future potential.
- Recruiting, hiring, and training employees who do not “fit” the organisation’s values, or who do not possess the requisite talent, results in eventual failure or mediocrity.
An article1 on employment costs describes an expensive hiring mistake, the cost of a “mis-hire,” as including the unconscious avoidance, denial, or toleration of underperforming or indifferent employees. The higher the position level, the faster the cost of such an error increases. Brad Smart, founder of Topgrading, Inc., cited in the article, puts the potential cost of a mis-hire at:
- 14 times salary for employees earning a base salary under US$100,000.
- 28 times salary for employees earning US$100,000 to US$250,000.
Besides the typical direct and indirect costs of finding new, qualified employees (recruiting, interviewing, reference checking, lost productivity in the first months, and so on), employers need to consider long-term opportunity costs. These include substandard service; lower morale and substandard performance in others because of passive resistance; missed deadlines; customer dissatisfaction with product quality or customer service; a lack of innovation caused by disengagement or lost trust in the company; and, unfortunately, missed sales opportunities.
The long-term financial implications
Imagine a business unit with annual revenue of US$250 million, operating at a 15% margin. Led by 12 global and regional leaders who cost, on average, US$300,000 per head, the impact of mis-hiring a single leader for the team can be truly devastating for the business unit. Two mis-hires at the leadership level will present a big problem. Three will result in long-term damage. Using these figures as the basis for an example calculation, the business impact becomes even clearer.
| Scenario | Number of mis-hires | Total cost (US$) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 mis-hire | 8.4 million |
| 2 | 2 mis-hires | 16.8 million |
| 3 | 3 mis-hires | 25.2 million |
Consequently, the potential financial impact of mis-hires on a business unit with annual revenue of US$250 million at a 15% operating margin (US$250,000,000 × 15% = US$37,500,000) can be as significant as a 67% reduction in the operating margin. The hypothetical impact on the operating margin, using the same three scenarios, is as follows.
| Scenario | Calculation | Reduction in operating margin |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 8.4 million ÷ 37.5 million | 22.4% |
| 2 | 16.8 million ÷ 37.5 million | 44.8% |
| 3 | 25.2 million ÷ 37.5 million | 67.2% |
This result represents a huge impact on the organisation’s bottom line, considering the effort and assets invested in such a business. Not only the leadership team but shareholders as well should be very concerned about scenarios that adversely affect profits and growth. The last thing shareholders want is to put the return on their investment at risk, which would be unacceptable. More to the point, the last thing employees want is to find themselves hunting for new jobs as a result of incompetent and inefficient leadership of the entity.
A story with an unhappy ending, unless rewritten
Put this way, in light of actual numbers, the financial impact of appointing weak leaders is a very clear, troubling, and compelling story. A serious issue faced by many organisations today is the lack of transparency (or ignorance) about actual costs or, indeed, little or no attempt to find out the true impact. This lack of transparency and understanding can trigger extensive hidden costs, in the form of wasted resources, financial expenditure, and lost time for all stakeholders, from the employee to the leadership team to shareholders. Hidden or not, these costs take a toll on all of us as we continue, over and over, to pay them.
Leadership roles are critical for developing the business and outperforming industry peers in this extremely competitive market environment. By not spending enough quality time finding the right people, and therefore appointing the wrong ones to these roles, many organisations defy all their stakeholders: shareholders, board members, management, employees, suppliers, clients and customers, and the community at large. Discovering, hiring, engaging, developing, and retaining only true, strong, and capable leaders to grow your business is the road to success.
1 Denise Corcoran, “Shocking Costs of Hiring Mistakes,” EmpoweredBusiness.com (October 30, 2013).
Want your leadership team to think and act differently?
Our facilitation, workshops and keynotes help leadership teams face hard questions and leave with decisions.
Explore Leadership Facilitation & Capability