Or how a CEO’s random idea in a meeting gets immediate support while a junior employee’s brilliant suggestion gets ignored? This happens every day, and it is a bigger problem than most people realise.
The Status Game
Here is what’s happening:
We don’t judge ideas based on how good they are. Instead, we judge them based on who is talking.
If someone is famous or powerful, we automatically assume their ideas must be valuable. If someone is unknown, we barely pay attention — even when they are right.
This creates a broken system. Good ideas from regular people get buried. Bad ideas from famous and powerful people get pushed forward. And everyone loses.
Why We Fall for It
Our minds take shortcuts to deal with all the information thrown at us. Three big shortcuts cause this problem:
Shortcut 1We assume that if someone is good at one thing, they must be good at everything
When a successful actor talks about health advice, we listen — even though acting has nothing to do with medicine.
Shortcut 2We follow the crowd
If everyone else is paying attention to someone, we figure there must be a good reason. This is why people with lots of followers seem more believable, even when they bought those followers.
Shortcut 3We use fame as a filter
There is too much information out there, so we use status to decide what is worth our time. It feels safer to listen to someone famous than to take a chance on someone unknown.
The Social Media Illusion
Social media has made everything worse. Now anyone can buy fake followers and fake engagement. They use these numbers to look influential, and once they look influential, they become influential. It is like counterfeiting credibility.
People who know how to game the system rise to the top, while those with actual expertise but no social media skills stay invisible. The whole thing becomes about appearance rather than substance.
At Work, It Is Even Worse
In companies, this problem gets supercharged. When your boss has a bad idea, you can’t just ignore it or scroll past like you would online. Speaking up might hurt your career. So bad ideas from the top go unchallenged while good ideas from below never make it up the ladder.
The higher someone’s position, the less honest feedback they get. People tell them what they want to hear. Their ideas — good or bad — move forward without proper testing. Meanwhile, great solutions from regular employees die in suggestion boxes that nobody reads.
What We Can Do About It
The good news is that organisations can fight back with some smart changes:
- Anonymous feedback systems let people share honest thoughts without fear
- Designated skeptics whose job is to challenge ideas, no matter who suggests them
- Structured decision-making that evaluates ideas before revealing who came up with them
- Direct communication channels that let lower-level employees talk to senior leaders
- Real rewards for dissent — not just saying you value different opinions, but actually promoting people who speak up
A Better Way Forward
These biases made sense in ancient tribes, where the oldest or most experienced often did have the best ideas. But in today’s complex world, expertise is specialised and good ideas can come from anywhere.
The teenager in their bedroom might understand social media better than any Fortune 500 CEO. The nurse might have better ideas about hospital efficiency than the administrator. The customer service rep might know more about what customers actually want than the executives.
We cannot just rely on individual awareness to fix this. Knowing about the bias is not enough — we need to build systems that actively counteract it. Otherwise, we will keep amplifying the wrong voices while silencing the ones we need to hear.
The next time you find yourself dismissing an idea because of who said it — or accepting one for the same reason — pause. Ask yourself: What if this exact same idea came from someone else? Would I still feel the same way?
That pause might be the first step toward hearing what really matters instead of just who is loudest.
Want your leadership team to think and act differently?
Our facilitation, workshops and keynotes help leadership teams face hard questions and leave with decisions.
Explore Leadership Facilitation & Capability