Strong leaders are critical factors in growing the business and outperforming industry peers, especially in today’s competitive market environment. They must act as true role models, providing practical rules and structure. Without such a framework, chaos, confusion, and disarray ensue, leaving employees uncertain, indecisive, and disengaged.
Distinctions Between Authentic and Pretentious Leadership
The definition of leadership continues to evolve today as change—in technology, consumer behaviour and needs, employee expectations, and other factors—drives every aspect of business. The need to upgrade certain managerial skills is increasingly becoming more than just wishful thinking. In fact, such expertise in the following skills, which do not fall into the category of traditional capabilities, has now become a necessity to sustain successful outcomes through authentic leadership:
- Leaders without self-knowledge and a full comprehension of their own capabilities and limits reflect pretentious authority. The more self-aware and empowered a leader feels, the better able they are to develop excellence in individual performance and organisational results. Unlike genuine leaders, who have no need for such displays, pretentious leaders flaunt their credentials like a badge of honour, often without possessing genuine or in-depth expertise.
- Authentic leaders exhibit compassion and caring for their people, while weak and pretentious leaders—who may display callous disregard for their workforce—drain their employees of motivation and engagement.
- With clarity, genuine leaders acknowledge where they want to go and with whom they can get there. They possess a clear mission with well-defined steps to reach their objectives. Pretentious leaders, who are likely to have a broad or vague vision, are often in disarray and only serve to confuse their employees about the direction in which the company is heading.
- True leaders make responsible and objective decisions based on facts and data, not emotions. In some cases, however, intuition that is based on valid experience may also be feasible. Overall, such leaders are transparent in the decision-making process, while pretentious leaders toss out the need for transparency because they “know best,” even if the data is partial or unclear.
- Building long-term relationships for genuine leaders is a skill based on mutually beneficial outcomes, resulting in positive credibility. Pretentious leaders often “drop names” to impress others, demonstrating their self-importance.
- A true leader is willing to encourage creativity and embrace open-mindedness to boost innovation and inclusiveness throughout the workforce. On the other hand, pretentious leaders often possess closed minds and narrow fields of vision.
Beyond such nontraditional skills, multiple essential character traits, such as the ones listed below, underlie the success or failure of a leader. The difference in approach clearly distinguishes a genuine leader from a pretentious one.
| Authentic trait | Pretentious trait |
|---|---|
| Ability to drive major transformational change and innovative initiatives | Indecision and procrastination |
| Ability to lead, not with assumed authority, but with a convincing vision and compelling ideas | Authority based on power |
| No fear of failure, accompanied by willingness to undertake complex, yet calculated, risks; comprehension of disparate facts and trends without personal bias | Inability to take major risks that would reflect poorly on self |
| Capacity to listen to what is said (or not said) and recognition of whom they should listen to | Dismissive of others’ opinions |
| A focus on achieving the best outcome for all | A focus on what is best for me |
| Comfortable with unexpected changes; calm, clear thinking to act without hasty and mindless decision making; flexibility of thought and action to determine the most suitable solution | Inability to process unanticipated events, leading to uncertain and faulty decisions |
| Exceptionality and uniqueness of self and company | A focus on profitability rather than on what self and company offer |
| Openness to renewal of spirit and regeneration of mindset and talent on an ongoing basis | Little emphasis on employee development and ongoing training |
Warning Signs of “Playing” a Leader
Occasionally, a pretentious leader manages to hide the true nature of inexperience and inappropriateness for the job. Yet, perceptive individuals can easily see through the web of incompetence by recognising the following clues:
- The so-called leader exhibits a tendency to focus on appearance over substance. For example, the leader may take surface action to look busy and attentive without delving too deeply into the potential consequences of the decision.
- Inconsistency between the leader’s words and actions is often apparent. Promises made to appeal to the workforce or shareholders may sound attractive. However, in the end, the leader does not deliver what was pledged.
- Prioritising personal gain over team success offers another glimpse into pretentious behaviour. Such individuals place more emphasis on ensuring that their own image looks good, particularly in the public arena, and may take credit for another’s creative ideas or positive achievements.
- When situations go wrong, as they tend to do under pretentious leadership, the person responsible for the failure avoids accountability and inevitably blames everyone else.
- While a genuine leader is open to feedback and recommendations through an open-door policy, pretentious leaders are resistant to feedback, particularly if it is critical or negative. They also dismiss new ideas; after all, they believe that their way is best. Or, perhaps, they are too unmotivated and like to keep things the way they have always been done.
Overcoming the Temptation to “Play” Leader
For those leaders who may be new to the position and have a firm commitment to the well-being of the company and the workforce, several techniques can help them reject the temptation to simply play at being a true leader. For example, by being open to recognising signs of the impostor syndrome, they can swiftly squash any such tendency in themselves as well as others in a leadership role.
Further, they can build genuine confidence in their abilities through competence, learning, and heeding expert advice from trusted individuals, honest advisors, and knowledgeable mentors. With such input, they can learn to focus on the long-term impact of their decisions, rather than narrowly considering only short-term perception and goals.
The Enduring Value of Authentic Leadership
Leadership, whether on a personal or organisational level, requires clarity, compassion, knowledge, confidence, humility, courage, and a host of other critical traits. Today’s complex and chaotic world demands authenticity in leadership to transform problems into solutions, and questions into answers.
True leadership requires the audacity to do what is right.
For any individual who aspires to a leadership role, cultivating genuine qualities and capabilities is the answer to success and achievement both in life and in business. Working in partnership with colleagues and individuals in all levels and functions of the organisation can be a positive step toward reaching mutually beneficial goals. Focusing on authenticity and being “real” sends the right message and garners the right results.
Want your leadership team to think and act differently?
Our facilitation, workshops and keynotes help leadership teams face hard questions and leave with decisions.
Explore Leadership Facilitation & Capability