But some companies go no further than introducing a plan, without determining its potential for success. Ultimately, failed programmes result in wasted time and resources, harming the company’s bottom line along with employee morale. Throwing money at traditional, “feel-good” HR approaches that have been proven to fail over time is not the answer.
Why, then, do companies continue to implement such programmes? And how can they be designed to succeed?
Reason 1No accountability or measurement
In some situations, the HR professionals responsible for running the programmes might be newcomers, with little or no practical experience in developing and implementing them. Exacerbating these scenarios, management oversight might be minimal, where overworked managers have no time, budget, or even interest in the matter. Further, leadership may only pay “lip service” to offering such programmes to the workforce. Without oversight or support from leadership, there may be no means of evaluating and measuring the success of these programmes and the outcomes they produce.
Organisations require accountability from leaders at all levels when it comes to people management. There is no point in designing an HR programme if leadership does not truly support it, does not understand how it works, does not care whether it is effective, and does not believe in it. But the need for accountability also extends to employees, who should take charge of, and be accountable for, their personal and career development, as well as for discovering what they lack in terms of self-knowledge. Without such ownership, it is easy to understand why many career development, reward, and other programmes do not deliver the performance results that companies seek.
Reason 2Too much emphasis on trends
HR practitioners, like professionals in every other field, monitor market trends. To retain valuable talent, they believe that the company should keep up with such trends, particularly if industry peers do so, often without determining whether the programme suits the company.
Introducing a new programme in its infancy, untried and unproven, often leads to failed endeavours and negative results. Simply following one’s competitors is not the answer. In fact, the very concept of a “trend” is something that eventually goes away. HR needs to develop programmes that have staying power and deliver concrete results.
Reason 3Misalignment between employee and employer, or programme
Many organisations misuse far too many resources hiring, developing, retaining, and rewarding “the wrong people” through so-called feel-good programmes that might produce only incremental improvement. If employees’ personal needs and interests are not compatible with the company’s mission, they are unlikely to contribute to the success of the company or to benefit from any HR programmes offered by leadership. The more aware employees are of their capabilities and wants, and the more they align with a company’s business requirements, both technical and cultural, the better the organisation should be able to outperform the competition.
Companies today are redefining and transforming organisational roles as they seek new ways to become more efficient and cost-effective. Consumer behaviour is also changing, with consumers expecting more from businesses and providing clear feedback, both positive and negative. Further, technology is driving change in many parts of company operations, from product and service design to delivery and beyond. Helping the company meet these challenges requires HR programmes that motivate and develop individual employees, who should be working in tandem with the employer.
Misalignment is also a problem between the employee and the HR programmes on offer. Sustainable and successful strategies demand in-depth research, thoughtful planning, and effective implementation. What good is a programme that no longer meets the needs of its employees when market demands, demographics, and other factors change? Short-term success is a missed opportunity, a band-aid, a quick fix. The key to creating a sustainable strategy is understanding what makes the HR framework viable and responsive to the changing needs of the workforce. And only leadership, in conjunction with representatives from different segments of the employee population, can determine that answer.
Reason 4Not forward-looking
Markets change, as do the skills and talents of the workforce needed to sustain organisational growth. This constant evolution of the external environment demands monitoring by leadership in order to provide the products and services clients want efficiently and effectively. Without the right talent, the company cannot satisfy customer needs. Although a workforce lacking the appropriate skills may somehow be able to supply the products and services, the end result may not be reliable, high-quality, or free of mistakes.
Lack of skills inevitably leads to dissatisfied clients, which leads straight down the road to long-term trouble and a gloomy forecast for the company’s survival. If managers do not know their subordinates, their skills and talents along with the skills and talents they want to develop, the ability to transform the company as demands change will not exist. Is the HR function sufficiently versed in what the company needs, going forward, in terms of talent and skills? Objective research on what the workforce is, what it needs to be, and how it needs to get there are essential steps toward company growth. Such proactive effort paves the way to uncovering workforce requirements that will satisfy leadership goals while developing talented employees.
Short-term thinking is present today in many organisations at all levels, from top to bottom. Unfortunately, without long-term vision and strategy, employers cannot design successful career development or reward programmes either. If management does not know what it wants to achieve in the future, how can the company attract and hire the requisite talent?
Reason 5Little or ignored feedback
Communication is key for any HR programme to succeed. Completing the design of a sustainable programme is useless without giving clarity about the plan to the very people who are going to benefit from it. All the time and effort spent designing the programme is wasted if leadership does not recognise that different segments of the workforce may view the programme differently, even negatively. Some groups may even require different means of accessing the programme because of work schedules, skills and abilities, and other factors.
Successful organisations possess knowledge, expertise, and talent, with an emphasis on feedback and open communication about the issues they face and the programmes under development. Individuals operating in different functions should work together to resolve difficulties and initiate new ideas. Different stakeholders (leadership, managers, employees, outside parties) have the potential to offer diverse perspectives on the task at hand. Choosing the right team can determine success, failure, or mediocrity. But without considering their perspectives, and by ignoring useful feedback, the company will suffer.
Transforming failure into success
A key ingredient of success for the leadership team is getting to know and understand the true needs and desires of the workforce, to ensure positive outcomes from any HR programme. To truly maximise returns on people through the programmes offered, managers should focus time and effort on these five areas:
- Invest in transparent people management practices.
- Focus on common sense.
- Build trust among employees.
- Do not tolerate, and unknowingly reward, self-interest.
- Get “only” the right people to do the job.
Whatever programme is in place, the company will not, and cannot, outperform in the marketplace with individuals who make only the bare minimum of effort. To boost the success and long-lasting effects of organisational strategy, HR must do its homework. Know what makes a programme work, plan the design elements with careful insight, test it, roll it out, and monitor its effectiveness as the environment changes. Leadership buy-in is critical for any undertaking that requires efficient use of time and money, effective communication, ongoing training, and long-term sustainability.
Accountability, a long-term vision, incorporation of employee input into organisational plans, and informed decision-making based on concrete information are all essential factors in ensuring the company’s future growth.
Together, they create a framework for transforming potential failure into definite success.
Looking for the talent you already have?
We help organisations see their workforce clearly, so that they hire, develop and keep the people their strategy depends on.
Talk to us